This delicious tomato pie features roasted tomatoes, a layer of fresh basil leaves, a cheesy goat cheese and Parmesan filling, all atop a thick biscuit crust. No mayonnaise needed.
When I started out on this little pie adventure, I had intended to make a Southern Tomato Cheese Pie - the classic pie with a biscuit crust, tomatoes, cheddar cheese and a topping involving more cheese and mayonnaise. I have no doubt that it's a fabulous pie, but somewhere along the way to making that pie, I made this pie. While definitely inspired by the classic, it is decidedly different, but a still wonderfully delicious tomato pie :) And no mayonnaises needed.
So I decided to call it Northern Tomato Cheese Pie, with a tongue-in-cheek nod to my north-of-the-border spin on the southern classic. I kept the biscuit crust, because ... biscuit crust!! On top of that is a cheesy filling, with chunks of goat cheese, Parmesan, a couple of eggs to hold it all together (but not so much egg that it became a quiche), a touch of cream and lots of pepper. Then there's a layer of fresh basil leaves. Topping it all of is a generous layer of fresh, thick-sliced roma tomatoes.
This pie is pretty much all my favourite flavours all together in one slice and it was everything I imagined ... and more! The biscuit crust bakes in to a generous base, that pairs beautifully with the tangy cheese and rich, roasted tomatoes. This would be a great meatless dinner served with a side of fresh greens, a delicious and pretty brunch dish or a lazy weekend breakfast treat.
Make this in a skillet or use any deep-dish pie plate and enjoy it warm or at room temperature.
Cook's Notes
- Be sure to leave your goat cheese in nice-sized chunks, as there is possibly nothing nicer than finding those big puddles of warm goat cheese in your pie later :)
- Don't skimp on the tomato layer. As you can see from the "slice" photo (below recipe), the biscuit layer cooks up nice and thick, so you want to keep your topping in balance. I did one layer of over-lapping tomatoes, starting from the outside, then added another ring around the outside.
- The top, exposed edge of the biscuit crust browns quickly. Check your pie around 20 minutes in and place a piece of aluminum foil loosely over-top if edge is brown enough already, to prevent further browning.
- Even though it's the height of fresh tomato season, with lots of great tomatoes available, for my money, nothing beats a roma/plum tomatoes for this type of dish. They release less moisture, they hold their shape well when roasted and they keep their awesome rich red colour.
- Fresh basil leaves are a really nice addition to this pie, so if you can use them, I'd highly recommend that. If unavailable, a generous sprinkling of dried basil leaves would work.
- Don't forget the finishing salt. While I do add salt and pepper to the top of the pie before baking, I love to finish with some Maldon salt crystals. It's a small touch that make a big difference in the finished dish.
Tomato and Goat Cheese Pie with Biscuit Crust
Ingredients
Crust:
- 2 cups all-purpose flour
- 1 1/2 tsp baking powder
- 1/2 tsp baking soda
- 1/2 tsp kosher salt, (less if using fine salt)
- 6 Tbsp unsalted butter, cold, cut into 1/2-inch cubes
- 3/4 cup buttermilk, (or make your own buttermilk by adding 2 tsp. lemon juice or white vinegar to 3/4 cup regular milk)
- 1 1/2 lbs roma tomatoes, sliced about 1/4-inch thick
Filling:
- 1 cup goat cheese, crumbled (don't crumble too fine - leave quite chunky)
- 1/2 cup Parmesan, coarsely grated(I use the large holes on my box grater)
- 2 large eggs
- 1/4 cup heavy 35% whipping cream
- Freshly ground pepper
- 6-8 leaves Fresh basil, whole or torn a bit if really large)
- Additional Parmesan for sprinkling on top of tomatoes
Instructions
- Make the crust: Combine the flour, baking powder, baking soda and salt in a medium bowl. Whisk well to combine. Add cold butter cubes and use your fingers to rub the butter in to the flour until they are pea-sized-ish pieces. Add about half of the buttermilk. Using a fork, stir to combine. Begin adding a bit more buttermilk while you continue to mix with a fork, adding only enough to bring the dough together into one mass. Remove to a piece of plastic wrap. Press in to a 1-inch thick disc, wrap tightly and refrigerate for one hour.
- While the dough is refrigerating, place slices of tomatoes on a triple-layer of paper towel to drain. Be sure to allow them to sit on the paper towel for at least 30 minutes.
- Prepare filling by combining all the filling ingredients in a medium bowl. Stir to combine, but don't break up any large chunks of goat cheese. Set aside.
- Preheat oven to 425 F.
- When dough has chilled, remove to a well flour surface and using a rolling pin, roll in to a large enough circle to just fit your skillet or pie plate (bottom and sides). Place rolled dough in pan and press to fit. Pinch the top edges a bit to make it a little pretty, if you like.
- Pour filling in to pie shell and spread to an even layer. Top filling with basil leaves. Arrange tomatoes on top by making over-lapping rings, starting from the outside and working your way in to the center. Go back and add a few more in a ring around the outside edge, so you have a nice layer of tomatoes. Season the tomatoes with a generous bit of salt and freshly ground pepper and sprinkle with an additional tablespoon or two of grated parmesan, if you like. If your side crust is extending well above your filling, push it down a bit, to within about 1/2-inch of the filling level, just so it doesn't over-brown as it cooks.
- (I didn't have any issues with needing a baking sheet underneath in my skillet, but if your pie seems really full in your baking dish, you may wish to bake it on a baking sheet, just to be sure).
- Bake in preheated 425 F. oven for about 30 minutes, checking top edges of crust after 20 minutes. If already browned nicely, loosely place a sheet of aluminum foil over-top for the last 10 minutes of baking. Check pie by inserting a butter knife in the centre to confirm the filling is set (there may be a little bit of moisture on top from the tomatoes, but the filling may still be set well underneath).
Nutrition
Nutritional information provided for general guidance only and should not be relied upon to make personal health decisions.
Hi! I'm Jennifer, a home-cook of many years and a lifelong seeker of delicious food! I'm an equal opportunity eater. I enjoy eating all the foods!
sunsprout says
What is the recommended pan size? Apologies if it is written and I missed it!
Jennifer says
My fault, as I didn't really specify. My cast iron skillet used here is 8 inches across the bottom and 10-inches across the top. Any pan in that size range will work :)
Sunsprout says
Thank you! My skillets were all too big, so I went with a 9” springform and it was perfect! I also exchanged the goat cheese for left over gruyere and it was so delicious. Thank you for an amazing (and easy!) recipe.
Jennifer says
Glad you enjoyed it and yes, this is delicious with all kinds of cheese :) Thanks!
Deanna says
Defo "Jennifer's Muskoka Tomato Pie" it shall be known as. Thanks :)
Jennifer says
Lol! Thanks :)
Erin says
Am I missing how long this bakes for? About to put it in the oven and I don't see a time.
Jennifer says
Sorry Erin. The photo seems to be covering up the last instruction. I'm going to fix it now, but in the meantime ...
Bake in preheated 425 F. oven for about 30 minutes, checking top edges of crust after 20 minutes. If already browned nicely, loosely place a sheet of aluminum foil over-top for the last 10 minutes of baking. Check pie by inserting a butter knife in the center to confirm the filling is set (there may be a little bit of moisture on top from the tomatoes, but the filling may still be set well underneath).
Tricia @ Saving room for dessert says
Oh my goodness! This is absolutely gorgeous. My husband's aunt used to make a wonderful tomato pie - with all that mayo and cheese :) I like your version and especially with that biscuit crust. Beautiful!
Jennifer says
Thanks Tricia. I'm still going to try that traditional pie before the summer is done :)
Chris Scheuer says
This would definitely be a summer meal for me. I love your new take on an old classic!
Jennifer says
Thanks Chris :) I have had it for dinner for the past 3 nights! Really hits the spot.
Thomas Sauer says
Not only was this absolutely delicious, but it was also a couple of Seasons & Suppers first for me: first time I went from reading recipe to making it in less than six hours and more importantly, first time I've made a pie crust. Wow. This is another winner.
Jennifer says
So nice to hear! And I have done that read-make-eat in short order thing a few times. So glad you enjoyed it :)
Laura | Tutti Dolci says
This pie looks incredible, an absolute must try with my garden tomatoes!
Jennifer says
Thanks Laura :)
Midge says
Thanks so much Jennifer. I will heed your advice and report in after Tuesday.
Katrina says
Yum!! I will definitely be making this (and taking your advice to leave bid goat cheese chunks!) This looks so good!
Jennifer says
Thanks Katrina. The chunks of goat cheese were one of my favourite parts ;)
Midge says
Jennifer - love, love love the look of this, going to try to make for company on Tuesday. I'm not confident at making crusts but will forge ahead anyway. One easy question can it be served at room temperature?
With thanks - Midge
Jennifer says
Hi Midge and thanks :) I think you'll love this pie! Crust making is not my forte either, so I hear you. Just remember that this is a biscuit dough, so will be a bit different than a pie crust dough. It's quite moist, but rolls out really easily with liberal sprinklings of flour (both on top and underneath). Also, if you roll it out just big enough to fit your pan, it will be about twice as thick as a pie crust dough would be. That's what you want. And yes, this pie is lovely at room temperature. Enjoy!
Cheyanne @ No Spoon Necessary says
As much as I love the southern classic, I am going to have to say I love your "northern" version a little bit more! And I haven't even tried it yet! I just LOVE that you used goat cheese and parmesan! This is a tomato pie fit for a queen! NEED! Cheers, Jennifer!
Jennifer says
Thanks so much, Cheyanne. I am such a goat cheese lover, it was calling at me from the fridge! One day I'll get around to trying that other pie ;)
Lynda says
Sorry, found the cooking time, love your recipes!
Jennifer says
Thanks so much, Lynda :)
Lynda says
How long do you bake the pie
Mary Ann | The Beach House Kitchen says
Oh my goodness Jennifer, this has to be the most gorgeous pie ever! That crust, those juicy tomatoes! You've got me absolutely drooling! I just got to pick some fabulous tomatoes from a neighbor's garden, so I know what I'll be making!
Jennifer says
Thanks so much, Mary Ann. It's a really delicious pie and I've been enjoying the left-overs from the fridge (keeps very well!)